Penny Dreadful Recap for Season 3 Episode 5 “This World is Our Hell”
Posted by Katherine Recap | Hollywood, TV[For Penny Dreadful “This World is Our Hell” or any other recaps on Fetchland, assume the presence of possible spoilers.]
Showtime Summary:
This World is Our Hell. Hecate and Ethan struggle; Kaetany reveals a truth to Malcolm; Frankenstein succeeds with Hyde’s formula.
Two themes run through in this episode which works especially well because one of those themes is partners/duos. The other theme, wholly more Penny Dreadful, illustrates that monsters spawn monsters: violence breeds violence, and hatred can only make more hatred. This cycle continues to infinity if not for a break in the pattern and a brand of pattern interrupt this powerful can only be made by a saintly soul, a martyr to the tune of Joan of Arc (for instance) sacrificed for the sake of others. An ideal this pure can’t live in this episode because as the title states, we’re in Hell here. The characters are all flanked by thirsty demons crawling though the desert. In fact many of our heroes are thirsty demons themselves and we can hardly tell the difference anymore. Thus we find this episode teeming with said monsters, they’re paired up and ready to die for the sake of revenge – not a single one afraid of the Hell that awaits because they each believe their hellish mission can’t possibly get any worse. “This World is Our Hell” feels like the hilarious Far Side comic pictured here. They’re in Hell anyway… so, might as well make the most of it and take down their enemies. Difference is, the episode seriously lacks jocularity. Lucky for you, Fetchland doesn’t.
Frankenstein and Hyde – Lennon and McCartney
Innovators with a long history of working both together and apart, these two are mixologists with science and medicine the same way Lennon and McCartney made music. At the top of their field but always striving anyway to improve, they’re dead set on the impossible tasks of healing themselves through the process of creation. This duo struggles with inner demons and expresses their feelings in their work to benefit others in the hope of somehow fixing themselves. Meanwhile the impact they have on people with their work doesn’t just transform their human guinea pigs, it changes them too – forever. Lennon and McCartney created wondrous songs that forever changed the musical landscape of the world. Their songwriting blended Lennon’s poignance and rebellion with McCartney’s cheerful ingenuity making all that once seemed simple, even common somehow fresh and new. Our two medical marvels share similar traits. Frankenstein models Lennon to the core: moody and deep with major issues but obviously a genius who means well, he’s met his match with Hyde. Henry Hyde has that handsome directness and solid skill that matches his partner at every turn. They match up and are even stronger together. As the music of the Beatles unleashed a whole new world of sound, these two doctors break through the boundaries between life and death, good and evil, love and hate. Speaking of love, it seems inevitable that a woman will come between them exactly as history tells the story of The Beatles breakup.
Hecate and Ethan – Kermit and Piggy
Hecate’s relentless pursuit of Ethan, a creature quite different from herself, mirrors the indomitable adoration Miss Piggy has for her sweet froggy. Piggy basically wears Kermit’s resistance down over the years with constant pursuit; much like Hecate with Ethan. Kermit barely pays attention her for the longest time but eventually starts to see her charm and ends up falling for Piggy, even with all of her flaws clearly. This is the attraction trajectory for Ethan in this episode. Completely aware Hecate’s a demon witch with a mission to take him to Hell, he falls for her anyway. She asks, “Shall we unleash demons, thee and me?” and then at last Hecate gets the answer she’s been craving along with some hot-but-also-severely-dehydrated desert sex. Hecate and Ethan are both animals in their own way and mis-matched while also somehow perfect for each other just like Piggy and Kermit. For all of Miss Piggy’s vanity and diva violence, her charisma always shines through. She’s exciting and her confidence entices much like that political pork loin named Trump. Nobody can squelch Piggy’s self esteem and don’t we all wish we had just a strip of that bacony belief in ourselves? Humble and nervous Kermit certainly does and much like Ethan, he struggles to be his fullest self but this lady beside him helps with self-acceptance for she’s the Platonic ideal of such. Thanks to Hecate’s influence, Ethan is finally ready to face his furious father and just in time too because it’s goin’ down NOW.
Malcolm and Kaetany – Thelma and Louise
Just like Thelma and Louise, these two pursue an impossible mission. It’s suicide, really, to overcome a demon power much greater than themselves and all the while they maintain deeply ingrained personal vendettas mixed with painful memories and road trip challenges. As Thelma and Louise illustrates the struggle of women in society through an arduous road trip on the run, Malcolm and Kaetany enlighten the Penny Dreadful narrative with insight into the Apache struggle of the early American West with their hardship. Murray and Kaetany reek of emotional wreckage as they share their struggle stories. Malcolm feels guilty for all his trespasses against people of color against the backdrop of Kaetany’s tragic loss – the entire Apache nation. His people are gone. It turned us into monsters, he explains to Malcolm. The US Army sent five thousand soldiers to kill the last thirty nine Apache, overkill doesn’t even begin to describe this kind of cruelty. We see how this played out in the final scene as Ethan’s father replays the night the Apaches came and destroyed his family, one innocent victim at a time. In fact, the only family member they left alive was Ethan’s father, now filled with hatred and vengeance – a monster in his own right. He says looking at Malcolm is like “looking in the mirror” and can’t understand how Murray can ride next to Kaetany who he calls “an animal”. But what about Kaetany? That snakebite Hecate unleashed was a killer, no? It doesn’t seem so from the preview clips for next week where we see Kaetany kicking ass once again. He’s magical, that man. And, not to get too technical, but we’re all animals, Mr. Talbot – you included. So, this duo haven’t driven off the cliff Thelma and Louise style quite yet but it seems inevitable at the rate they’re going.
Bartholomew Rusk and The Marshal – Benson and Stabler
The two detectives, the New Mexico Marshal and Rusk, the Scotland Yard investogator who took Ethan to New Mexico for “justice”, have finally proven themselves worthy of recapping in their own right, old school Law and Order SVU style. In this episode Rusk finally talks about his own history rather than just Ethan, Ethan, Ethan and capturing Ethan. Thus he’s finally a character unto himself. It is their unified goal to locate Ethan and bring him to justice but they’re also increasingly aware more is going on than just simple criminality. In the last episode Scotland Yard asked The Marshal if he knew anything of the occult. When The Marshal replied no Rusk suggests he look into it… Now in this hellish episode the desert is getting to everyone and Rusk disavows the oath to follow the law and says he’ll shoot Ethan in the back and butcher all of his kind. This guy’s goin’ rogue and, of course, it’s just when we’re starting to like him. He’s the Stabler of the duo, full of rage and defiance, while The Marshal is Benson, all empathy and reason. These are the two most typical reactions people have to horrific crimes and simply summarize why the Benson and Stabler dynamic worked so well for those first twelve seasons of SVU. We see how chasing a monster has turned Rusk into his own version of a monster and how all those in pursuit of Ethan begin to share his qualities. It’s as if merely seeking him out arouses the demon inside them, implying that maybe to catch a monster one must become one, even if temporarily. The only exception to this is, of course, the glorious Olivia Benson an no mere mortal can live up to that ideal, except maybe taylor Swift’s cat.
Much of the episode revolves around the dry expanse of desert where Ethan and Hecate struggle to survive as the other two duos, Malcolm & Kaetany and Rusk & The Marshal hunt for them. There’s a brief stint in the bowels of Bedlam as Frankenstein and Hyde discover that electricity really is the missing ingredient for relieving inner demons but even that feels like a dry run. For both Ethan and Malcolm the episode ends in confrontations with Ethan’s actual father while Hecate tries to sleep in a bed surrounded by terrifying antique dolls. Even a demon can get creeped out with those glass-eyed monstrosities haunting their dreams. Just like Miss Piggy would struggle to sleep with a pea under her mattress, Hecate lies awake and bothered. She needs Kermit and we can tell that this demon doesn’t like feeling needy. Not one bit.
–Katherine Recap